All-Stars

[Host Brian]

We're at the merge, so might as well open this now for discussion. If PG can successfully finish her return to the game, she makes AS. She has a good resume so far of:
1. Great game until swap.
2. Saved herself from the evil JFP with an immunity.
3. Explodes at him, where he reveals his game to her.
4. Fucks over Reed (tragic, I know) to return to the game as an Outcast.
5. Will do everything in her power to vote JFP out .

On the flipside, JFP is 100% AS worthy, whether you hate the guy or not. He bumblefucked his way into being a leader, made alliances with half the cast, blindsided Greg for no reason, and then had a reign of terror on NuGenji where he got out Reed and PG, two fan favorites that could have possibly won the whole game. Now, he's at merge with PG coming back to slay his ass and make him into a pre-juror. 

Beyond those two I'm willing to say Coach and Siska are likely AS candidates as long as they don't fuck up majorly, or everyone else in the cast gets substantially better. Baylor's being a delightful mix of fun and bitchy, so she makes for another possible candidate. Amber maybe could make it if her awful gameplay continues for just being awful, but I think she's gonna go UTR as soon as JFP leaves and in turn lose her chance of a spot. Alex, Rob, and Corinne all are narrators like Charlie, who might come back if certain people are forceful on 6 returnees. Abi and Eliza are playing up characters that are both more annoying then anything else now. In saying that, bonus points to Abi for actually sticking to her character and giving us some pretty funny screenshots of her convos.  

[Austin Carty]

At this point, people I'd like to see in AS:

JFP: For obvious reasons. If he goes out now or he goes out later, he's earned his spot.
PG: Especially if she's the Ronin, because that's a bad-ass title. As much as I may love ragging on her because of the video confessionals, she's played a solid game and provided us tons of entertainment.
Rob: Rob has been entertaining me with his TC answers and confessionals, and he's a solid player and narrator. His confessionals are pretty good, compared to the others anyway.
Baylor: She's playing the bitch card hard, bur is still somehow UTR. She's at the merge and not in immediate danger, so I wanna see how she acts down the line before continuing this endorsement.

I like Coach, bur his  confessionals dropped off significantly and sometimes I feel like the other players in not knowing where his head is at. SISKA is a chill dude, but I need more from him in that department as well. I could see Abi making it, but as an AS I'd rather not have her continue the shtick there. The others don't particularly stand out to me, even though I do like Corinne and Alex, and I don't think the're contenders.

[Host Brian]

Coach's confessionals got better in a video form.

[Malcolm Freberg]

I feel like for now Coach, PG, and JFP are the only true worthy ones. What were the nicknames we went through?

PG: The Ronin
Coach: The Dragon Slayer
JFP: So my optionss. I personally like the polygamist

[Host Aras]

Current 100% all stars for me
PG
JFP *puke*

High chance
Abi
Siska

Contenders
Coach
Eliza
Alex

Not gonna happen
Baylor
Corinne
Amber

[Woo Hwang]

PG got fukd

[Austin Carty]

Dec 30, 2014 12:30:16 GMT Host Aras said:

Current 100% all stars for me
PG
JFP *puke*

High chance
Abi
Siska

Contenders
Coach
Eliza
Alex

Not gonna happen
Baylor
Corinne
Amber

But what about Rob?

[Host Aras]

Dec 30, 2014 20:58:25 GMT Austin Carty said:

Dec 30, 2014 12:30:16 GMT Host Aras said:

Current 100% all stars for me
PG
JFP *puke*

High chance
Abi
Siska

Contenders
Coach
Eliza
Alex

Not gonna happen
Baylor
Corinne
Amber

But what about Rob?

What about him?

[Host Brian]

I think Rob's a possibility, but he'd be taking the last spot if he made it. He's just above a boring narrator, because of his TC answers. I'd also put Baylor above any narrators (Alex, Rob, Corinne) and on par with Abi because the two of them are sticking 100% to their characters. Unlike Eliza or Corinne who try to appear one way in confessionals and another with the other players, they're both playing solid UTR games while speaking in Spanish/being a brat to everyone in the game. Also calling it now, Baylor's gonna become more evil as soon as JFP leaves.

In terms of nicknames, PG being The Ronin is perfect and I'm glad that people like that one, I thought it was clever. Abi should be The Foreigner, Baylor should be The Brat, and Siska should be The Artist. JFP has so many possibilities, but The Little Dictator and The Tyrant are the two I like the best.

[Lex Van De Blue]

JFP already has a nickname. Figga.

[Woo Hwang]

The more boring the better I found in these type of games. If nobody is looking at you then you're doing something right.

[Lex Van De Blue]

Boring may equal good gameplay, but it's shitty viewing.

[Alina Wilson]

I say PG and JFP should be locks, for pretty obvious reasons. Stars of the show and are respectively essentially the biggest hero/villain at this point, at least from my POV. Coach is a third choice right now, but I wouldn't consider him or anyone else besides JFP/PG a lock yet in my opinion. I need to see more as it unfolds.

[Host Brian]

Fishing out AS because it's been awhile. As of right now, my 6 would be JFP, PG, Baylor, Coach, Corinne, with a 6th final undecided spot which could go to Alex or Abi.

[Austin Carty]

Alec is in a solid spot to win the game, so he probs gets a spot. I'd give one to JFP and PG for sure. I don't really want Coach there, his flat out refusal to make a move at F8 rubbed me the wrong way, but I understand that you guys want him. I'd give the last two spots to Baylor and Rob, personally.